Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince.

[.star*]

Originally Posted by Lazzaro

My friend thinks this as well, I'm not so sure cos Dumbledore said it was risky doing that with something that can think for itself and they were talking about animals so surely it would be more dangerous for it to be in a person.

Also, even if Harry was one then Voldemort still wouldn't die because he's still have the piece that's left in him. Although if it was Harry + he died then it would be getting rid of one.

edit -

Spoiler: actually say harry was a horcrux, then if they got rid of all the others apart from the piece that's left in voldemort, well they could try kill voldemort then kill harry afterwards to stop him coming back.

[Lazzaro]

Originally Posted by Siouxsie

Spoiler: I think harry's gonna have to die first, and it'll be snape that kills voldemort.

[.star*]

Originally Posted by Lazzaro

Ooh possibly, he'll be all redeemed then! Although I always imagined Snape dying to save Harry. How intriguing. I want to know what happens dammit!!

[Laura*]

Originally Posted by Lazzaro

and laura "only one can live while the other survives", doesn't mean harry has to kill him...

Hmm, but I'm sure I remember reading at some point that Harry was the only one who could defeat Voldemort.

He's "The Chosen One" mind.

[Lynnie]

I cant take all of this, when does the next book come out?!

[Rebelius]

Spoiler: sorry but Dumbledore said that Voldy liked to make his horcruxes after significant killings, His Seventh was likely to be after he killed the boy from the prophecy (Harry) and so I doubt Harry could be a horcrux. I just don't see it happening to be honest.

"Realistically, I don't think I'm going to be able to do real work on it until next year. I see next year as the time that I’m really going to write seven. But I've started and I am doing little bits and pieces here and there when I can. But you’ve seen how young Mackenzie still is, and you can bear actual witness to the fact that I do have a very small, real baby, so I'm going to try and give Mackenzie what I gave David, which is pretty much a year of uninterrupted “me time,” and then I'll start writing seriously again."

[honey bunny]

i reckon that harry is definately a horcrux, i thought of it this morning then had to come on here and see if anyone had thought of it too!!!!
when V gave him the scar he wasnt trying to kill him.. he was transfering part of his soul... thats why V has never wanted the death eaters to kill harry, i reckon that in the last book harry will have to kill himself!!! maybe thats a bit far fetched but i definately think he is a horcrux!!!



oh and lindsay why the hell are you bothering to comment on here if you havent even read the book, and as you keep on reminding us, will never read the book!!! sounds to me that you just want to piss on our bonfire!!!

[.star*]

Originally Posted by honey bunny

i reckon that harry is definately a horcrux, i
when V gave him the scar he wasnt trying to kill him. He was transfering part of his soul... thats why V has never wanted the death eaters to kill harry, i reckon that in the last book harry will have to kill himself!!! maybe thats a bit far fetched but i definately think he is a horcrux!!!

I don't think it will be although I can see where some people who think that are coming from. As for not wanting the Death Eaters to kill Harry, fair enough but then why would Voldemort want to kill Harry himself like he's tried to do in practically every book?

[honey bunny]

Originally Posted by Siouxsie

fair enough but then why would Voldemort want to kill Harry himself like he's tried to do in practically every book?

hmm... maaaaaaaaaaybe he wasnt trying to kill him, maybe it just appeared that way...or maybe i am getting carried away

i think i am gonna go and read the books again and try and get some solid evidence... i'll be back in a week or so with another theory!! hehe